| Pick | Team | Player | Pos | Former Team | Pullback |
| 1 | Wayne Newtons | Neil Walker | 2B | MAR | Ryan Doumit |
| 2 | Livingston Last Place | Justin Smoak | 1B | SAR | Wil Myers |
| 3 | Livingston Last Place | B.J. Upton | OF | LV | Brett Anderson |
| 4 | Wayne Newtons | Gaby Sanchez | 1B | ARK | Randy Wolf |
| 5 | Wayne Newtons | Pedro Alvarez | 3B | HIL | Mike Minor |
| 6 | Livingston Last Place | Zack Britton | P | BR | Ted Lilly |
| 7 | Livingston Last Place | Bud Norris | SP | BRI | Anibal Sanchez |
| 8 | Wayne Newtons | Yadier Molina | C | AMI | Brandon League |
| 9 | Wayne Newtons | Drew Stubbs | OF | ARK | Erick Aybar |
| 10 | Livingston Last Place | Mark Reynolds | 3B | BRI | Jeff Karstens |
| 11 | Livingston Last Place | Danny Espinosa | 2B | BRI | n/a |
| 12 | Wayne Newtons | Jon Jay | OF | AMI | Manny Banuelos |
| 13 | Wayne Newtons | Stephen Drew | SS | NWK | Kyle Farnsworth |
| 14 | Livingston Last Place | Neftali Feliz | RP | SAR | Daniel Bard |
| 15 | Livingston Last Place | Travis Snider | OF | HPG | Dellin Betances |
| 16 | Wayne Newtons | Chris Young | OF | CAR | Heath Bell |
| 17 | Wayne Newtons | Andrew Bailey | RP | LV | Jayson Werth |
| 18 | Livingston Last Place | Jimmy Rollins | SS | PHI | Michael Cuddyer |
| 19 | Livingston Last Place | Jose Valverde | CL | BR | Gavin Floyd |
| 20 | Wayne Newtons | Nick Hundley | C | ARK | n/a |
|